Tent fabrics - which is best?
If you're thinking about buying a home tent, you'll come across a confusing mix of different tent fabrics, from polyester to polyester-cotton, and a range of different brands. It's hard to know which is the best. we try to figure things out
Cotton and Canvas Tent Fabrics
Canvas is a traditional tent fabric that has many great tent properties.
In the old days, canvas was made of hemp, but now tents are made of cotton. So tents advertised as "canvas" or "cotton" are actually made of the same material.
Why canvas or cotton are the best materials for tents?
Compared to artificial tent fabrics, cotton is very thermally insulating. You won't get as hot on a warm day, and you won't get as cold on a cold day. There are many different tent fabrics, some are much more expensive than others. But are they worth it?
Each tent fabric has its pros and cons.
Which tent material is best depends on your needs. For example, do you need a tent that is easy to transport, or are you looking for a tent as your vacation home for a week or more?
Cotton is a breathable fabric that absorbs water. This means you are less likely to experience condensation problems.
Due to its weight and insulating properties, canvas/cotton tents can be quieter and less noisy if there is a breeze.
This fabric lasts a long time and is more resistant to harmful UV rays.
The Problem of Canvas and Cotton as Tent Materials
Cotton and canvas are very heavy and bulky. This means that transporting the marquee to the campground can be problematic—probably enough to keep you from fitting it in the trunk of your car. It also makes pitching more effective.
You usually need to "weather" the canvas before using it. This includes leaving a new tent in the rain (or under a garden hose) for the canvas to expand and fill in the stitching and holes in the fabric. If you don't, your new canvas tent may leak.
Cotton and canvas require more maintenance. Since it absorbs water, you'll need to let the material dry before putting away the tent, which takes much longer than man-made materials. Don't do this and your tent will get moldy.
It may snag more easily and cause a tear, which can turn into a large tear.
Cost - Cotton or canvas is much more expensive than man-made fabrics.
Coating and treatment of cotton tents
Cotton tents should not be coated with a waterproof membrane like polyester tents because cotton needs to remain breathable and is already UV and water resistant.
However, some manufacturers have lightly treated cotton for water repellency. The cotton still retains its breathability, but the treatment means that if there's a light shower or morning dew, water will run out of the tent. Innovations like this make cotton more suitable for family camping because it helps reduce drying time. (Especially important for campgrounds that insist you leave the course by 10am!).
How about the polyester cotton tent?
Polycotton is a blend of synthetic polyester and cotton. Essentially, polyester-cotton fabric is a cotton fabric with some polyester woven into it.
All the good qualities of cotton (or canvas) can be found in polyester cotton tents. They also have some drawbacks (such as cost, weight, and maintenance), but the polyester in the weave makes them slightly more mold-resistant than cotton or canvas, and the polyester also helps reduce the risk of large tears.
So which tent fabric is the best?
As you can see, each fabric has a lot of good properties, but also some not-so-good ones.
To me, the feel and insulating properties of canvas (or polyester cotton) make for a great family tent, especially if you're camping on vacation.
If you ever get the chance to visit a camping show, tent display, or even chat with campers at the campsite with a canvas or polyester cotton tent, I highly recommend comparing it to a polyester tent.
Wait until the sun comes out for a few minutes. Step into a canvas or polyester-cotton tent and feel pleasantly cool (not cold). Then walk into a polyester tent and you'll immediately feel and breathe the baking air.
If it's cold and a little breezy, do the same test again. Canvas or polyester-cotton tents will feel warmer and quieter than polyester tents. It feels like a cozy sanctuary.
So for family vacation tents, if you can afford, transport and pitch, I recommend choosing canvas, cotton or polyester cotton.
However, for quick weekend camping (definitely backpacking!), faux fabrics are the way to go. While some air-frame tents can make pitching cotton or polyester-cotton tents easier and more practical, let them work on weekend camps as well.
Polyester fabrics also work well for vacation tents. Just remember to open the vents, and if your tent's doors and windows allow air to pass through, use it when it gets hot.
If you're camping outside the summer months, the insulating properties of canvas/cotton/polycotton are definitely worth it.
There are many kinds of clothing fabrics, and people tend to compare similar fabrics. Such as oxford fabric and canvas. So what are the obvious differences between them?View More
There is some debate over whether or not Oxford cloth is the same as canvas. Canvas is a heavier fabric, while Oxford cloth is a lighter weight fabric. Canvas is also a bit rougher to the touch.View More
Oxford cloth is a new type of fabric with various functions and wide applications. At present, the main products on the market include: lattice, full-stretch, nylon, and tige. Oxford cloth is also called Oxford spinning. It uses polyester polyester-cottonView More
Canvas (canvas) is a thicker cotton or linen fabric. Named because it was originally used for sails. Generally, plain weave is used, and a small amount of twill weave is used. Multi-strand yarn is used for warp and weft.View More
Related InformationCan you put a roof top tent on a RAV4?how to build a deck for canvas tentwho makes the best roof top tentdometic roof top tenthow to put on a roof top tentbcf roof top tentWhat is the cheapest hard shell roof top tent?Tent fabrics - which is best?where to buy yakima roof top tentquick release awning bracketshow to store roof top tentcvt awningdarche roof top tentarb batwing awningdune roof top tentWhat is the cheapest roof top tent?how to make a roof top tentclamshell roof top tentHow do I stop condensation on my roof top tent?how to mount roof top tentkings roof top tent reviewarb awning 2500x2500hard shell roof top tent australiawhat is the point of a roof top tentIs a vehicle awning worth it?how much does a roof top tent weighbest roof top tent australiawhat is the best roof top tentarb deluxe awning room with floor priceCan you put a roof top tent on a canopy?retractable awning for suvhow to install a roof top tenthow wide of a roof top tent can you fit on a 5' truck bedWhat is the best hard shell roof top tent?how to store a roof top tentwhat roof rack for roof top tenthow to make hard shell roof top tentarb awning reviewhouse roof awningDo I need a roof rack for a roof top tent?roof top tent kingsarb quick release awning bracketwhat is the advantage of a roof top tenthow to make roof top tent more comfortablewhy use a roof top tent